11 conspiracy theories about search, Google and Massive Tech



Conspiracy theories are all over the place on-line. Few are shockingly true, most usually are not, however one shared trait amongst all conspiracy theories is {that a} easy fact could possibly be blended up in a murky sludge of truth and fiction. 

That is very true for conspiracy theories associated to look, Massive Tech and Google due to the general public’s misconceptions about every platform.

As search entrepreneurs, we all know the groups at Google and different tech firms are doing loads for the search and promoting world, however we will’t deny that Massive Tech has gotten their arms caught within the cookie jar greater than as soon as.  

Whether or not truth or fiction, conspiracy theories might be entertaining, weird and freaky. Listed here are a few of the juiciest conspiracy theories surrounding Massive Tech, Google, and search, and the info behind these theories.

Principle #1: Advertisers and your cellphone are recording and listening to you on a regular basis.

What’s true: Your cellphone can document you once you use voice search and sure purposes.

I’m certain most of us have heard this principle floating round. Though there’s no concrete proof that your cellphone or gadget is recording you on a regular basis, there’s proof that your gadget can document your conversations, together with your voice searches inside sure purposes.

For instance, in 2019, Bloomberg reported that Fb employed contract employees to transcribe voice messages from its Portal video app, which customers could not have been conscious of. Like Amazon’s Alexa, when customers activate voice search by saying phrases corresponding to “Hey Alexa” or “Hey Portal,” the appliance is probably going storing the person’s speech. 

Fb claimed that the transcribers had been utilizing these messages to enhance the voice-activated software program algorithm however had halted the usage of human overview. Each Fb and Amazon give customers the choice to show off this function and opt-out of human overview.

As for that scarily-accurate advert that appeared to focus on you primarily based in your final dialog? Ask anybody working in paid promoting. They will clarify that all of it comes all the way down to profiling knowledge collected from quite a few sources, together with cookies, third events, fingerprinting, searching historical past and behavioral knowledge. 

Nevertheless, with third-party cookies going extinct, the way forward for promoting will look fairly completely different for each entrepreneurs and shoppers alike.

Principle #2: Advertisers, governments and hackers are secretly controlling your units.

What’s true: Your tech gadget is inclined to manipulation.

Do not forget that well-known Burger King industrial that performed in the course of the Tremendous Bowl just a few years in the past? It grabbed everybody’s consideration, however it additionally pressured Google Dwelling units to begin speaking about Whopper burgers with out anybody’s consent. Little question it was an excellent advert, however it uncovered a weak point within the units that stay within the privateness of our personal houses.

Incidents corresponding to this usually are not one-off; Amazon’s Echo units had been reportedly triggered by commercials and tv exhibits. Though each firms have patched up this challenge by instructing their respective units to “ignore” particular instructions, it leaves the door open for future gadget manipulation by malicious events or sensible jokesters.

If that’s not worrying sufficient, in 2018, researchers used subliminal and hidden instructions (utilizing sound undetectable to human ears) to govern units, forcing telephones to go to sure web sites, dial cellphone numbers, ship textual content messages, and even take photos; additional proving how extensive this door might be if exploited by hackers or different events. 

As many have lengthy suspected, governing our bodies, together with the U.S. authorities, are simply as able to gadget manipulation. The New York Instances lately reported that legislation enforcement and intelligence businesses can “reliably crack the encrypted communications of any iPhone or Android smartphone.” 

Get the day by day e-newsletter search entrepreneurs depend on.

Principle #3: Google prioritizes its personal model over different websites.

What’s true: The Division of Justice filed a lawsuit towards Google for anticompetitive conduct.

There have been rumors that web sites using Google’s platforms, corresponding to Google Analytics and Google Adverts, will rank increased on the search engine outcomes web page.

Google’s John Mueller busted this rumor ages in the past on Twitter, saying there is no such thing as a penalty or reward for utilizing (or not utilizing) Google Analytics.

Whereas utilizing Google Analytics isn’t a assure that you simply’ll get a lift in natural search rankings, the problem begs whether or not Google manipulates search by prioritizing its model over all else, primarily performing as a monopoly. 

Kind in any search question into Google, and also you’ll see its proof of Google merchandise all over the place on the display:

  • Google Adverts proper beneath the search bar
  • Data panels with contextual info 
  • “Folks Additionally Ask” questions and solutions
  • Google Maps and Google Enterprise Profile listings
  • YouTube movies
  • Google Buying advertisements

Though it creates a improbable person expertise, these merchandise additionally forestall customers from participating with different platforms and opponents exterior of Google’s ecosystem, holding all income going to at least one supply. 

Digital entrepreneurs usually are not the one ones who’ve seen this invasion on the search engine outcomes web page. In 2020, the Justice Division filed an antitrust lawsuit towards Google for monopolistic practices and anticompetitive conduct. Justice Division legal professionals stated, “This lawsuit strikes on the coronary heart of Google’s grip over the web for tens of millions of American shoppers, advertisers, small companies and entrepreneurs beholden to an illegal monopolist.” 

Principle #4: Google’s search algorithm is racist and sexist.

What’s true: Biases exist, and there are current efforts to enhance search outcomes.

Search algorithms are designed as a course of to resolve issues by retrieving or sorting info inside a knowledge construction, so may an algorithm replicate racist or sexist biases?

Final yr, a bunch of Democratic senators wrote a letter to Google highlighting how its search algorithm appeared to point out biases that perpetuate racist stereotypes. This isn’t the primary time Google has come below fireplace for this challenge. 

A number of examples have demonstrated current biases towards black girls in search outcomes, together with a comparability between queries like “unprofessional hairstyles” and “skilled hairstyles,” which present a stark distinction in picture outcomes.

Nevertheless, to amend this challenge, Google has made steps to diversify its picture outcomes by altering its search algorithm. Safiya Noble, a professor at USC and writer of “Algorithms of Oppression: How Search Engines Reinforce Racism,” additionally notes that “after years of that includes pornography as the first illustration of black women, Google made modifications to its algorithm.”  

Principle #5: The federal government is working with Massive Tech to spy on you.

What’s true: Massive tech works with the federal government and on a number of initiatives, together with surveillance, protection and cloud computing. 

Whereas it’s unclear if the federal government companions with tech firms to spy on you, a number of studies affirm the federal government’s and tech giants’ partnerships in cloud computing.

For instance, the New York Instances reported that Google was concerned in a Pentagon contract referred to as Undertaking Maven, “a army program that makes use of synthetic intelligence to interpret video photos and could possibly be used to refine the focusing on of drone strikes.” Nevertheless, hundreds of Google workers demanded the corporate withdraw from the challenge, fearing the potential misuse of AI.

Though CEO Sundar Pichai said the corporate wouldn’t develop AI for weapons, he asserted that Google would proceed to work with the army in lots of areas for future developments.

Google isn’t the one Massive Tech firm working with the federal government. Amazon and Microsoft even have subcontracted with a number of federal legislation enforcement businesses and the Division of Protection, offering companies corresponding to cloud and industrial options. 

In 2019, Microsoft was additionally awarded a $10 billion authorities contract referred to as JEDI to supply cloud options for the Pentagon.

Principle #6: Google’s search algorithm is anti-conservative. 

What’s true: Google censors pretend information or misinformation.

There’s an limitless variety of theories on the market in regards to the nefariousness of Google. Nonetheless, probably the most common notions is that Google suppresses web sites that symbolize conservative viewpoints and information sources. Nevertheless, the reality is much less nefarious than many wish to imagine.

With disinformation spreading like wildfire on the web, tech firms corresponding to Google, Twitter, and Fb all take duty in battling pretend information. In 2017, Google started cracking down on the unfold of misinformation in its search engine outcomes by rolling out a search algorithm replace referred to as Undertaking Owl

This search replace focused pretend information and conspiracy theories by eradicating search outcomes, search options and wealthy snippets that promote misinformation, hate, violence, hurt and specific content material. 

Controversial matters and heavily-biased content material had been additionally flagged for overview and elimination. Along with this effort, Google emphasised authoritative and factually right content material. E-A-T, which stands for experience, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness, has turn out to be a tenet for the way Google determines content material high quality and search rankings. 

No matter the place content material leans politically, Google’s purpose is to ship factual, high quality content material to the person, not misinformation and faux information. 

Principle #7: Massive Tech is interfering with elections and politics.

What’s true: Tech firms corresponding to Google and Fb permit political advertisements on their platforms.

In relation to the world of politics, tech firms usually discover themselves in very sticky conditions. For instance, in 2019, the Federal Commerce Fee fined Fb $5 billion for knowledge misuse and privateness violations within the Cambridge Analytica scandal. The obtained knowledge was used to focus on voters in the course of the 2016 presidential election. The controversy delivered to mild the position tech firms could play in influencing voters utilizing their platforms.

Paid advertisements are a big income for Google and Fb, that are the most important ad-selling firms on this planet. Political advertisements are additionally allowed on each platforms (relying on the nation and area), with sure restrictions to assist accountable practices.

To focus on customers on both platform, political advertisers should undergo a inflexible verification course of and are given restricted home windows of time the place advertisements are run. Throughout sure election marketing campaign intervals, advertisements usually are not allowed

Whether or not these guardrails promote accountable marketing campaign practices is debatable. 

Principle #8: Google’s Incognito isn’t actually incognito.

What’s true: Google is going through a lawsuit for gathering person knowledge in incognito mode.

Most of us are below the impression that if you should surf the net privately on Google’s Chrome browser, you need to use Incognito mode. Nevertheless, many customers is probably not conscious that their exercise remains to be seen to numerous events, together with the web sites they go to.

This confusion over privateness has led to shoppers slapping a $3 billion lawsuit towards Google for not disclosing its knowledge assortment practices to customers when utilizing Incognito mode. 

The overall assumption is that when a person is searching in Incognito mode, there’s absolute privateness, that means no searching historical past, cookies or private info is saved. However the truth is, Incognito mode nonetheless permits entrepreneurs and advertisers to see your actions once you go to a web site throughout a session.

Despite the fact that cookies usually are not saved on Incognito browsers, advertisers can nonetheless determine items of knowledge by using knowledge corresponding to IP addresses and your browser kind, a course of referred to as “fingerprinting.” 

Principle #9: Tech firms use deliberate obsolescence to make you purchase extra.

What’s True: Apple paid $113 million to settle claims of deliberately slowing down iPhones. 

Deliberate obsolescence isn’t a brand new enterprise idea. From mild bulbs to pantyhose, many items producers discover methods to encourage shoppers to buy new merchandise when older fashions expire.

A number of years in the past, shoppers noticed this apply in motion when Apple admitted that it slowed down older variations of their iPhones by software program updates. Investigators stated that Apple knew of the slowdowns and labored to hide the knowledge from the general public. In consequence, the corporate paid $113 million to settle client fraud lawsuits and was fined 25 million euros by France’s competitors watchdog, DGCCRF.

Principle #10: Massive Tech search algorithms are pushing individuals towards extremism.

What’s true: Content material platforms are beginning to regulate and “de-platform” extremist content material.

A number of tech firms have come below scrutiny for search algorithms that doubtlessly amplify and counsel extremist content material, together with Amazon, Fb, Google and YouTube. 

Though every platform has its method of monitoring person preferences, their search options encourage customers to find new content material associated to their question, whether or not the content material promotes misinformation.  

In an investigative article, the Wall Road Journal reported that YouTube’s suggestions usually lead customers to channels that function conspiracy theories, partisan viewpoints and deceptive movies, even when these customers haven’t proven curiosity in such content material.”

Amazon has additionally been criticized for suggesting anti-Semitic kids’s books and Nazi propaganda. On the identical time, Fb’s inside paperwork present that since 2016, the corporate knew that “64% of all extremist group joins are attributable to [its] advice instruments.”

Because the rebel on the U.S. capitol, tech firms corresponding to YouTube and Twitter are ramping up their policing to take away content material that promotes extremist views, forcing extremist content material creators to hitch different platforms. 

One NPR article notes, “Whereas de-platforming hasn’t fully stopped the circulation of extremist content material on-line, it has helped marginalize extremists.”

Principle #11: Google manipulates advert auctions with price-fixing.

What’s true: Google faces a lawsuit for deceptive advertisers about its advert public sale processes.

Promoting is Google’s main income. In 2020, the corporate generated over $147 billion, roughly 80% of their yr’s complete income. 

Over tens of millions of advertisers rely upon the platform to generate paid visitors to their websites, getting into into auctions the place every can bid for priceless key phrases. Google controls this complete bidding course of, and its lack of transparency has turn out to be a difficulty of controversy.  

In one other antitrust lawsuit, the tech large was accused of price-fixing auctions and deceptive advertisers in regards to the means of bidding. There have been additionally accusations that Google and Fb conspired to agree, referred to as “Jedi-Blue,” round programmatic promoting, which might give Fb a “win-rate” assure throughout auctions. 

In consequence, many declare that Google is, but once more, participating in anti-competitive practices and ought to be held accountable.


Whether or not or not you imagine in conspiracy theories, there appears to be a consensus that Google and Massive Tech could have an excessive amount of affect over client knowledge, the media and politics. 

As legal guidelines and privateness rules evolve and lawmakers maintain these firms accountable, there’s little question that extra investigations will result in new info coming to mild.

Opinions expressed on this article are these of the visitor writer and never essentially Search Engine Land. Workers authors are listed right here.

New on Search Engine Land